Training Tip 2
I often hear things like "Barry is so talented" and "No one can ever be as good as WSL". Why not? I ask. "Because we can't train like that because no one is teaching like that any more."
Nothing could be further from the truth. Everyone teaches like that. Yip Man would only come to class when he felt like it. WSL would arrive well after the students had begun. Classes and instruction were short and to the point. The teachers didn't hover over the student making them do it right, but went off and had a cigarette and a cuppa.Modern teachers put more into their students these days than before, not less. The teachers lead the class, run around fixing problems for a couple of hours, not a few minutes, and vigilantly watch the students to make sure they don't make mistakes. They teach new things as fast as they can.
The problem is not in the teaching, but the students. The students no longer are willing to train alone for the hours needed, then go back for harsh correction, and cycle that until perfect. People are happy with imperfect - they either only practice in class, or get taught once, then practice that, without correction. Both approaches are not good enough. You need both halves to make a whole. It makes for incompete systems. Then, they go and teach in this way.... it is causing a degradation of the system.
I have had students turn up after 5 years after being taught part of Chum Kiu in a seminar, (which I don't do - I do not advance people in seminars - and no matter how clear I make it that seminars are to experience things not "officially" learn them for the first time, people do it every time). He said, I've been doing chum kiu now for six years, maybe it's time to learn the next section? I said show me. He naturally had lots of errors. He got angry and said, why didn't anyone tell me that in the first place? I said, did you go back to class and get someone to correct you? He hadn't thought it was necessary. Consequently, he quit. Sad, because he had potential.
But it illustrates a point. Students just don't get it. It needs to be perfect, not shoddy copies. And that needs lots of personal training AND lots of face time for corrections. You cannot practice enough in 3 classes a week to get anywhere. And without correction, training all day every day only makes errors and bad habits.
You need daily training AND lots of correction.
This is the real kung fu.